COLUMBIA, S.C. — The South Carolina Supreme Court said Wednesday that a sports bar chain could not recoup damages from its insurance policy over the COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent shutdown.
The ruling in Sullivan Management, LLC v. Fireman’s Fund Insurance Company is the latest victory for insurers as high courts across the country routinely side with them in such disputes. The decisions serve as a cautionary tale on the scope of all-risk policies for local business owners, who are seeing the windows for such pandemic-related lawsuits close.
The Iowa Supreme Court ruled in April that two restaurants could not collect damages over lost business following the governor’s indoor dining order. The Massachusetts high court delivered a similar ruling that same month. A Connecticut state judge in June tossed a case from the Mohegan Tribal Gaming Authority. And over a dozen restaurants lost a similar suit in July at the North Carolina Court of Appeals.
In South Carolina, the court agreed with the insurance company’s argument that there must be the “physical alteration, destruction, or permanent dispossession of property” to make an insurance claim. The inability to use the property is not enough to trigger coverage.
“Fireman’s Fund is pleased that the South Carolina Supreme Court concluded, like nearly every other appellate court in the country, that neither the presence of the COVID-19 virus nor related government shutdown orders cause physical loss or damage under its property insurance policy,” Brett Ingerman, a lawyer for the insurance company, said in a statement.
Lawyers for Sullivan Management, which owns the Carolina Ale House franchise, contested that point. They argued that the policy, which did not clearly define “physical loss” and “physical damage,” covers losses incurred when the property becomes “unfit or unusable for its purpose.”
Because the policy covers the costs necessary to “mitigate, contain, remediate, treat, (and) test for” communicable diseases, the restaurant owners argued they should have been able to collect insurance payouts.
Justin Lucey, who represented the restaurant chain, noted that justices punted decisions on several of the “most hotly litigated” policy terms to the district court. That includes the issue of communicable disease coverage.
In March 2020, Republican Gov. Henry McMaster signed an executive order prohibiting indoor dining. That May, he lifted the restrictions, and in October, he allowed restaurants to open at full capacity.
In many cases, the window for this litigation is closing, too. Most policies have a two-year limitation period, according to the Insurance Coverage Law Center.
(WATCH BELOW: More than 100 Meck County employees excluded from bonuses for recognition during pandemic)
©2022 Cox Media Group
State courts say no COVID-19 loss insurance for restaurants – WSOC TV & Latest News Update
State courts say no COVID-19 loss insurance for restaurants – WSOC TV & More Live News
All this news that I have made and shared for you people, you will like it very much and in it we keep bringing topics for you people like every time so that you keep getting news information like trending topics and you It is our goal to be able to get
all kinds of news without going through us so that we can reach you the latest and best news for free so that you can move ahead further by getting the information of that news together with you. Later on, we will continue
to give information about more today world news update types of latest news through posts on our website so that you always keep moving forward in that news and whatever kind of information will be there, it will definitely be conveyed to you people.
State courts say no COVID-19 loss insurance for restaurants – WSOC TV & More News Today
All this news that I have brought up to you or will be the most different and best news that you people are not going to get anywhere, along with the information Trending News, Breaking News, Health News, Science News, Sports News, Entertainment News, Technology News, Business News, World News of this made available to all of you so that you are always connected with the news, stay ahead in the matter and keep getting today news all types of news for free till today so that you can get the news by getting it. Always take two steps forward
Credit Goes To News Website – This Original Content Owner News Website . This Is Not My Content So If You Want To Read Original Content You Can Follow Below Links